Legal Insights October 22, 2026 By David Traywick

The Business Judgment Rule and Your HOA: When Boards Are Protected — and When They're Not

The business judgment rule is the shield every HOA board hides behind — and the SC Supreme Court's decision in Fisher v. Shipyard Village (2016) defines exactly where that shield ends. It protects only intra vires acts in good faith; ultra vires acts, bad faith, self-dealing, and failures to follow the governing documents fall outside it. The seven recognized defeaters, explained.

Community entrance landscaping at golden hour, illustrating HOA board authority limits

Every homeowner who has ever challenged an HOA board has heard the phrase. The board's lawyer says it like an incantation: business judgment rule. Courts won't second-guess the board. The decision stands. Go home.

It's half true — which is what makes it dangerous. South Carolina courts do defer to HOA boards. But the SC Supreme Court's most complete statement of the rule, Fisher v. Shipyard Village Council of Co-Owners, Inc., 415 S.C. 256, 781 S.E.2d 903 (2016), draws a hard boundary most boards would rather you didn't know about: the business judgment rule protects only intra vires acts — decisions within the board's authority, made in good faith. Step outside that boundary, and the shield drops. This post is part of Traywick Law's series on HOA problems in South Carolina.

This post explains what the business judgment rule actually protects in a South Carolina HOA, the seven recognized defeaters that strip the protection away, who has to prove what, and why the rule has never saved a self-dealing developer.

What Is the Business Judgment Rule in an HOA?

The business judgment rule is a doctrine of judicial restraint. Courts are not super-boards. When directors make a decision the law entrusts to them, judges won't substitute their own judgment for the board's — even if the decision looks unwise in hindsight.

The canonical South Carolina formulation comes from Goddard v. Fairways Development General Partnership, 310 S.C. 408, 426 S.E.2d 828 (Ct. App. 1993): "In a dispute between the directors of a homeowners association and aggrieved homeowners, the conduct of the directors should be judged by the 'business judgment rule' and absent a showing of bad faith, dishonesty or incompetence, the judgment of the directors will not be set aside by judicial action." 310 S.C. at 414, 426 S.E.2d at 832.

Dockside Ass'n v. Detyens, 294 S.C. 86, 362 S.E.2d 874 (1987) (per curiam), states it as a bar on review: the rule "precludes judicial review of actions taken by a corporate governing board absent a showing of a lack of good faith, fraud, self-dealing or unconscionable conduct."

Note what both formulations assume: a board acting within its authority, in good faith, making a judgment call. The entire doctrine is built on those premises. Remove any one of them, and there's nothing left to defer to.

The Controlling Framework: Fisher v. Shipyard Village Council of Co-Owners (2016)

Fisher is the case that matters — the Supreme Court's most recent and most complete business-judgment-rule framework for HOA boards. The dispute involved the Shipyard Village condo regime in Pawleys Island: years of water intrusion around windows and sliding glass doors, a board that told owners the leaks were their responsibility, and a fight over who paid for the building-envelope failure.

The Court's framework has three holdings homeowners need:

First, the governing documents don't displace the rule. The trial court had treated the master deed, bylaws, and the Horizontal Property Act as replacing the business judgment rule. The Supreme Court said no — the documents and the rule coexist. A board doesn't lose BJR protection just because covenants govern its conduct.

Second, the rule protects only intra vires acts. "The business judgment rule applies to intra vires acts of the corporation, but not to ultra vires acts." 415 S.C. at 271, 781 S.E.2d at 911. And it goes further: "any failure of the Board to comply with its affirmative duties under the governing documents" is likewise outside the rule. The opinion puts it bluntly: the business judgment rule "is not a cloak that protects a corporation from a violation of its own bylaws."

Third, one bad act doesn't poison the rest. Even if the board committed ultra vires acts, those acts don't preclude BJR protection for the board's separate intra vires acts made in good faith. Each decision gets judged on its own footing.

The bottom line from Fisher: "the Board will not be entitled to the protection of the business judgment rule if the jury finds that the Board acted beyond the scope of its authority, or acted with corrupt motives or in bad faith." 415 S.C. at 271–72, 781 S.E.2d at 911. That's the sentence to build a case around.

What the Rule Protects: Good-Faith Decisions Within the Board's Authority

Before the defeaters, understand what the shield legitimately covers — because overclaiming against a board that stayed inside the lines loses cases.

The rule protects judgment calls: which contractor to hire among qualified bidders, whether to repair or replace, how to prioritize projects within a budget, whether to grant a variance the covenants allow the board to grant. It protects decisions that turn out badly despite good process. As Kuznik v. Bees Ferry Assocs., 342 S.C. 579, 538 S.E.2d 15 (Ct. App. 2000), puts it: "The business judgment rule requires directors to act reasonably and in good faith. It does not expect perfection."

The protection assumes the S.C. Code § 33-31-830 standard was met: good faith, the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise, and a reasonable belief the action was in the corporation's best interests — in short, the fiduciary duty South Carolina board members owe. A board that became informed, deliberated honestly, stayed within its authority, and acted for the association gets deference — even when homeowners hate the result. Disagreement with the outcome is not a defeater. Now the defeaters.

Defeater #1: Ultra Vires Acts — Exceeding the Board's Authority

The first and most structural defeater. A board's powers come from the declaration (or master deed), the bylaws, and the Nonprofit Corporation Act. An act beyond those powers is ultra vires — literally "beyond the powers" — and Fisher holds the business judgment rule simply doesn't apply to it.

Baumann v. Long Cove Club Owners Ass'n, 380 S.C. 131, 138, 668 S.E.2d 420, 424 (Ct. App. 2008): "The business judgment rule only applies to intra vires acts, not ultra vires ones." Kuznik is to the same effect.

In practice, ultra vires looks like: levying assessments the declaration doesn't authorize; enforcing "rules" that were never properly adopted or recorded (remember S.C. Code § 27-30-130 — unrecorded governing documents may be unenforceable); spending association funds on purposes outside the corporation's stated purposes; or exercising architectural authority the covenants never granted. Members — suing derivatively — plus directors and the Attorney General can seek to enjoin ultra vires acts under S.C. Code § 33-31-304(b).

The homeowner's move: don't argue the board decided badly. Argue the board had no power to decide at all. That's a question of documents, not judgment — and the BJR has nothing to say about it.

Defeater #2: Fraud and Dishonesty

Fraud and dishonesty have defeated the business judgment rule since the doctrine's earliest formulations — Goddard names "bad faith, dishonesty or incompetence" as the trio that lifts the shield, and Dockside lists "fraud" among the showings that open the board's actions to judicial review.

In HOA practice, fraud looks like: misrepresenting the association's financial condition to the members; fabricating the basis for a fine or assessment; backdating documents; concealing the developer's continued control or the existence of side deals. Fraudulent concealment does double duty — it defeats the BJR and it tolls the § 33-31-830(f) limitations period.

Plead fraud with particularity and evidence, not adjectives. Courts punish conclusory fraud allegations; they reward bank records, contradictory minutes, and the email that says the quiet part out loud.

Defeater #3: Self-Dealing and Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest

A board member who votes the association's money to himself — or to an entity he controls — is not exercising business judgment. He's exercising self-interest. Dockside names "self-dealing" as a BJR defeater, and Kuznik confirms the rule "will not apply if the directors have engaged in self-dealing, fraud, or other unconscionable conduct."

The statutory machinery is S.C. Code § 33-31-831: conflict transactions must be fair at entry or properly approved after disclosure — by a majority of disinterested directors (a single director can never do it alone) or by the members with interested votes excluded. The § 831 machinery is illustrated in Kiawah Resort Assocs. v. Kiawah Island Cmty. Ass'n, 421 S.C. 538 (Ct. App. 2017), where the court discussed § 33-31-831's rule that a conflict-of-interest transaction requires approval by a majority of disinterested directors — a single director cannot authorize it alone.

The classic HOA fact patterns: the president's company holds the management or landscaping contract; a director votes to buy common-area land from the developer entity he also officers; the board approves above-market contracts with developer affiliates during declarant control. When you find the conflict, the BJR argument is usually over — the question becomes remedy.

Defeater #4: Bad Faith and Corrupt Motives

Fisher's formulation — no protection where the board "acted with corrupt motives or in bad faith" — is the defeater homeowners reach for most and prove least. Bad faith is not disagreement, not a bad outcome, not even negligence. It's knowing conduct against the association's interests.

The clearest example in Fisher's own record: knowingly enforcing a covenant provision the board knows is invalid — conduct the trial court in Fisher cited as a lack of good faith. A board that enforces a rule its own lawyer told it was unenforceable isn't exercising judgment — it's acting in bad faith, and the BJR doesn't cover it. Other markers: enforcing against a homeowner the board knows complied, while waving through identical conduct by insiders; manufacturing violations to punish a dissident member; acting on knowledge that makes reliance on others unwarranted (§ 33-31-830(c)).

Because bad faith is a state of mind, prove it circumstantially: the timeline, the disparate treatment, the ignored legal advice, the documents that contradict the board's stated rationale. Our companion post on what counts as bad faith by HOA boards works through the full taxonomy.

Defeater #5: Incompetence — The Duty to Get Informed

Goddard's trio — "bad faith, dishonesty or incompetence" — makes incompetence a standalone defeater, and § 33-31-830(a)(2) gives it content: the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise, which includes the duty to become informed before deciding.

Incompetence in HOA practice is usually omission, not commission: the board that never reads the financials; never commissions a reserve study; never asks what the management company is doing with the money; votes however the developer's representative suggests; or — the Renaissance Tower pattern — knows about a deteriorating condition for years and never acts. A board that decides without becoming informed hasn't exercised business judgment at all. There's no judgment to defer to.

The line matters: a board that hired engineers, got competing bids, deliberated, and chose wrong gets deference. A board that never hired anyone, never asked, and voted blind does not. Process is the difference.

Defeater #6: Unconscionable Conduct

Dockside names "unconscionable conduct" as a BJR defeater, and Kuznik adopts it: the rule "will not apply if the directors have engaged in self-dealing, fraud, or other unconscionable conduct." Unconscionability is the doctrine's conscience — conduct so far beyond the bounds of reasonableness and fair dealing that deference would be an embarrassment.

The fact patterns that get there: fines that metastasize through stacked fees into forfeiture threats (the "$75 fine became $4,000" phenomenon); using the assessment power punitively against dissidents; enforcing long-dormant rules selectively to drive out disfavored owners. Unconscionability often overlaps the other defeaters — it's the label courts reach for when the conduct shocks them even if it doesn't fit a neater box.

Defeater #7: Failing to Follow the Governing Documents

This is Fisher's most practical holding and the one boards violate most casually: "any failure of the Board to comply with its affirmative duties under the governing documents" falls outside the business judgment rule. Not some failures. Any.

The affirmative duties are in your declaration and bylaws: maintain the common areas; hold annual meetings; give required notices; follow the amendment procedures; enforce the covenants as written. A board that ignores them can't then claim judicial deference for the consequences. As Cedar Cove Homeowners Ass'n v. DiPietro, 368 S.C. 254, 261, 628 S.E.2d 284, 288 (Ct. App. 2006), put it: "The Association, which claims a desire for strict compliance with the covenants, may not escape from its own lack of compliance with the restrictive covenants."

This defeater is also the most homeowner-accessible, because it requires no proof of anyone's state of mind. Read the documents. List what the board was required to do. Show what it didn't do. The BJR doesn't apply to the gap.

Who Has to Prove It? The Challenger Bears the Burden

The burden structure is the board's real advantage, and homeowners should know it going in. The challenger bears the burden of proving the defeater — lack of good faith, fraud, self-dealing, unconscionable conduct. It doesn't shift to the board to prove its virtue, even when the challengers are defendants at trial. Dockside Ass'n v. Detyens, 291 S.C. 214, 217, 352 S.E.2d 714, 716 (Ct. App. 1987); Dykes v. Wild Wing Co., 2025-UP-299 (Ct. App. 2025) (unpublished).

But "burden on the challenger" doesn't mean "challenger loses." It means the case is won in discovery and documents: minutes showing no deliberation, financials showing no oversight, contracts showing no bidding, emails showing the real motive, the declaration showing the act was never authorized. Smith v. Dockside Ass'n, 2005-UP-139 (unpublished), confirms the challenger carries the burden with evidence of bad faith or unreasonable reliance. Build the record; the burden follows the evidence. Our guide on how to sue your HOA maps the forums, remedies, and pleading sequence.

The Business Judgment Rule Does Not Save a Self-Dealing Developer

The final point, and the one developers most want obscured: the BJR has never protected a developer that used board control for its own benefit. In Walbeck v. I'On Co., LLC, 426 S.C. 494, 515–16, 827 S.E.2d 348, 358–59 (Ct. App. 2019), the court stated: "We reject Appellants' argument that the business judgment rule precludes the existence of a fiduciary relationship between a developer in control of a homeowners association and the association's members" — and held that "a developer in control of a homeowners association may not make decisions that benefit the developer's own interest at the expense of the association and its members." 426 S.C. at 517.

In Walbeck II, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals in relevant part and reinstated the $1.75 million verdict. The principle is clean: the business judgment rule is a shield for volunteer homeowner boards making good-faith judgment calls. It is not a cloak for developers who kept the board as an instrument of self-dealing. When the developer's lawyer invokes the BJR, the answer is Walbeck I — and then the fiduciary-duty cases.

The business judgment rule, properly understood, is modest: courts defer to good-faith, informed, intra vires decisions. Everything else — ultra vires acts, fraud, self-dealing, bad faith, incompetence, unconscionable conduct, and failures to follow the governing documents — gets judged on the merits. Most HOA disputes that reach a lawyer's desk live on the defeater side of that line. The question is never really "does the business judgment rule apply." It's "which defeater fits these facts" — and whether the record proves it.

Traywick Law Offices can analyze your HOA dispute against the business judgment rule — the board's authority, its process, and which defeater fits your facts — and push for a favorable resolution efficiently. To get started, request a legal opinion through our intake page.