Wrongful Death Claims in South Carolina: Who Can File, What It Pays, and the Deadline
In South Carolina a wrongful death action is brought by the personal representative for the benefit of the spouse and children, then the parents, then the heirs. This guide explains the claim, the companion survival action, damages, court approval, and deadlines.
Losing a family member because another person or a company failed to act with care is a loss no lawsuit can undo. A wrongful death claim does not pretend otherwise. What the law can do is hold the responsible party accountable, recover the financial support and companionship the family has lost, and pay the costs the death imposed. South Carolina law sets specific rules for this claim. Who may file is not a matter of family agreement. What the claim covers is not the same as the claim the deceased person held while alive. And the deadline runs from the date of death, on a clock that starts while a family is still grieving.
This guide explains those rules in plain, sober terms. It covers the wrongful death statute in Title 15, Chapter 51, the order of beneficiaries, the companion survival action, damages, the court approval required for settlements, the three year deadline, the shorter path when a government entity is involved, and the probate step that must happen before suit can be filed.
This article is general information about South Carolina law. Every wrongful death case turns on its own facts, including fault, insurance, and family relationships that must be proved with records.
When Does South Carolina Law Allow a Wrongful Death Claim?
Section 15-51-10 creates the action. In substance, paraphrased from the code text, when the death of a person is caused by the wrongful act, neglect, or default of another, and that act, neglect, or default is such that the injured party could have maintained an action and recovered damages if death had not followed, the person who would have been liable if death had not followed is liable to an action for damages, even though the death occurred, and even though the circumstances make the killing in law a felony. If the wrongdoer also dies, the cause of action survives against that person personal representative, under the same section.
Two ideas in that text decide most cases. First, there must be a wrongful act, neglect, or default that caused the death. A fatal car crash caused by a driver who ran a stop sign, a death caused by a dangerous product, a death after negligent medical care, and a death from an unsafe property condition can all be tested under this rule, each with its own proof and its own additional statutes. A death that happens without any wrongful act by another, however tragic, does not create a wrongful death claim.
Second, the deceased person must have been able to sue if alive. Lawyers call this the underlying claim. If the deceased person, had the injury not been fatal, could have brought a personal injury action for the same conduct, the wrongful death action can proceed. If a legal defense would have defeated the deceased person own claim, that defense will be raised against the wrongful death claim as well. Fault of the deceased person is therefore central, as discussed below.
Who Can File a Wrongful Death Lawsuit in South Carolina?
Only one answer is correct, and it surprises many families. Section 15-51-20 provides that every such action shall be brought by or in the name of the executor or administrator of the deceased person. In current probate language, that person is the personal representative of the estate. A spouse, a parent, or an adult child does not file a wrongful death suit in an individual name alone, even when that family member is the main beneficiary. The suit is filed by the personal representative, for the benefit of the beneficiaries the statute names.
That means an estate must be opened in probate court and a personal representative appointed before suit is filed. If the deceased person left a will naming an executor, that nomination is presented to the probate court. If there is no will, the probate court appoints an administrator under the Probate Code priority rules. The appointment takes time. Papers must be filed, family information gathered, and, in contested situations, hearings held. Families who expect to file suit within days of a death are often surprised to learn that weeks can pass before the personal representative has legal authority to act. Starting the probate step early is not rushing a family. It is protecting the claim the family will later decide whether to pursue.
Section 15-51-42 confirms the point for settlements. Only a duly appointed personal representative, as defined in the Probate Code provision the section cites, has authority to settle wrongful death or survival actions. An insurer that asks a family member who has not been appointed to sign away a wrongful death claim is asking for a signature that lacks the authority the statute requires. Do not sign a release, a settlement statement, or an allocation between claims before the personal representative is appointed and advised.
To see the injury and estate related matters our firm handles, visit our Charleston practice areas page.
Who Receives the Money From a Wrongful Death Claim?
Section 15-51-20 sets the order. Every such action is for the benefit of the wife or husband and child or children of the person whose death was caused. If there is no such wife, husband, child, or children, then the action is for the benefit of the parent or parents. If there are none of those, then the action is for the benefit of the heirs of the deceased person.
Read the order as a ladder. The first rung is the surviving spouse and children together. Only if there is no spouse and no child does the claim move to the parents. Only if there is no spouse, no child, and no parent does it move to the heirs, a term that is determined under the Probate Code intestacy rules. A parent of an adult who left a spouse and children is not a wrongful death beneficiary under this order, even though the parent grief is real. A sibling is not in the first rungs and would be considered only through the heirs rung when no earlier beneficiary exists. These results can feel harsh. They are the statute order, and settlement papers must follow them.
Section 15-51-40 addresses how an amount recovered is divided. The amount recovered is divided among the parties named in shares as they would have been entitled to if the deceased had died intestate and the amount recovered had been personal assets of the estate. The same section allows a probate court, on motion by a parent or another party of potential interest when the decedent died intestate, to deny or limit a parent share if the court finds by the stated standard that the parent failed to reasonably provide support for the decedent as defined in Section 63-5-20 and did not otherwise provide for the needs of the decedent during minority. Family facts that families may prefer to keep private can therefore become part of a court record when shares are disputed. Early, candid advice helps a family plan for that reality.
What Is a Survival Action, and How Is It Different From Wrongful Death?
A wrongful death claim compensates the beneficiaries for their own losses from the death. A survival action preserves the deceased person own claim for what that person suffered before death. The two claims are often brought together, in the same suit, by the same personal representative, but they measure different losses and pay different recipients.
Section 15-5-90 is the survival statute. It provides that causes of action for injuries to real estate, injuries to the person, and injuries to personal property survive both to and against the personal or real representative of a deceased person, and the legal representative of an insolvent person or a defunct or insolvent corporation, despite any law or rule to the contrary. In a fatal injury case, that language keeps alive the claim the deceased person held for the injury itself. South Carolina courts have recognized that a survival claim can recover for the deceased person conscious pain and suffering before death, when there is sufficient proof the person was conscious and suffering, along with medical expenses tied to the injury. A leading discussion of that proof appears in cases applying Section 15-5-90, including the conscious pain and suffering analysis families should expect an insurer to demand with medical and witness evidence.
Section 15-5-100 connects the two claims on one item. Damages recoverable under either Section 15-5-90 or Section 15-51-10 may include reasonable funeral expenses, but those expenses shall be sought in only one action. Funeral costs cannot be recovered twice. Settlement papers should state clearly which claim carries the funeral expenses.
What Damages Can a Family Recover in a Wrongful Death Case?
Section 15-51-40 states the measure in broad terms. In every such action the jury may give damages, including exemplary damages when the wrongful act, neglect, or default was the result of recklessness, wilfulness, or malice, as the jury thinks proportioned to the injury resulting from the death to the parties for whom and for whose benefit the action is brought. Exemplary damages are another name for punitive damages in this setting, and they are not available in an ordinary negligence case merely because the outcome was fatal. They require the higher showing the section states.
Within that proportioned to the injury measure, South Carolina wrongful death damages are commonly presented in the groups families experience. Funeral and burial costs, as allowed by Section 15-5-100 and counted once. Lost financial support, meaning the income and benefits the deceased person would have provided to the spouse, children, or other beneficiaries over a working life, proved with earnings records, work history, and, in larger cases, economic analysis. The value of household services the deceased person provided, when it is proved rather than assumed. Loss of companionship, society, guidance, and protection, which for a spouse means the loss of a partner in daily life and for a child means the loss of a parent care, training, and presence as the child grows. Grief, mental anguish, and sorrow of the beneficiaries are recognized in South Carolina wrongful death law as part of the injury resulting from the death, a point long reflected in the damages the courts allow juries to consider in these actions, including the categories collected in Smith v. Wells, 258 S.C. 316 (1972).
Insurance limits shape what can actually be collected, as in any injury case. A fatal crash may involve an at fault driver policy, an employer policy when the driver was working, a commercial policy for a truck or a business, and uninsured or underinsured coverage held by the deceased person household. Finding every policy early is essential. Our explainer on South Carolina car accident deadlines and fault rules covers the fault and deadline framework that governs most fatal crash claims.
Does the Deceased Person Own Fault Reduce or Defeat the Claim?
Yes, it can. Because a wrongful death action depends on the claim the deceased person could have brought if alive, the fault of the deceased person is measured under South Carolina comparative negligence law. South Carolina follows modified comparative negligence, adopted by the South Carolina Supreme Court in Nelson v. Concrete Supply Co., 303 S.C. 243, 399 S.E.2d 783 (1991). Under Nelson, a plaintiff may recover if his or her negligence is not greater than that of the defendant. In the form families hear most often, recovery is allowed at fifty percent fault or less, reduced by that share of fault, and barred when the injured person fault is greater than the defendant fault.
Applied to a wrongful death case, that means a finding that the deceased person was mostly responsible for the fatal event can defeat the claim, and a finding of partial responsibility can reduce the recovery by that share. Insurers investigate fault in fatal cases with great care for this reason. Skid marks, vehicle data, toxicology, phone records, witness accounts, and expert reconstruction can all be contested. A family should expect the other side to present the strongest fault case it can build and should preserve its own evidence at once. Vehicles should not be released, repaired, or destroyed before a lawyer advises whether inspection is needed. Phones, photographs, and messages from the deceased person that bear on the event should be preserved, not deleted in grief or in an effort to tidy an account.
Why Does a Wrongful Death Settlement Need Court Approval?
Section 15-51-41 states the rule without exception for these claims. Any settlement of a wrongful death or survival action must be approved by either a probate court, a circuit court, or the United States District Court, as provided in Section 15-51-42. A private settlement agreement, signed at a kitchen table or in an adjuster office, is not complete until a court listed in the statute approves it.
Section 15-51-42 sets the process. Only a duly appointed personal representative may settle these actions. If no action is pending, the personal representative petitions the probate court or the circuit court for approval. The verified petition must set out the basic facts of the death, the facts about liability of the alleged wrongdoer, the amount of insurance available, the terms of the proposed settlement, the statutory beneficiaries, the heirs at law or appropriate devisees, the appropriate creditors and the amount of their claims, and, when counsel was retained, the terms of the agreement on attorney fees and costs. Counsel, when retained, signs a certificate stating the opinion that the settlement is fair and reasonable and in the best interests of the statutory beneficiaries and, in a survival action, the estate. The court holds a hearing, receives evidence it considers necessary, and issues an order approving or disapproving the settlement. Only after approval does the personal representative have power to conclude the settlement and sign the documents it requires.
Court approval protects everyone when it is done correctly. Beneficiaries, including minors who cannot protect themselves, get a court review of fairness. The party paying the settlement and those on whose behalf payment is made are, after an approved settlement and payment to the personal representative, relieved and discharged from further liability for distribution among beneficiaries, under Section 15-51-42(E). Families should budget time for this step. A settlement agreed in principle in one month may not be funded until a court hears and approves it in a later month.
How Long Does a Family Have to File a Wrongful Death Claim in South Carolina?
Three years from the date of death. Section 15-3-530(6) sets a three year period for an action under Sections 15-51-10 to 15-51-60 for death by wrongful act, and states that the period begins to run upon the death of the person on account of whose death the action is brought. Not from the date of the crash or the negligent care, if death followed later. Not from the date a family first speaks with a lawyer. From the date of death.
Three years is not a suggestion to wait three years. The personal representative must be appointed. Fault evidence must be gathered while vehicles, scenes, and witnesses are still available. Insurance must be identified. If settlement requires court approval, that process needs time after terms are agreed. A case that begins in the final months of the period leaves no room for a probate contest, a missing beneficiary, or a defendant who cannot be found for service. A claim not filed by the deadline can be barred, even when liability is clear.
What Changes When a Government Entity Caused the Death?
When the responsible party is a governmental entity or an employee acting within the scope of official duty, the South Carolina Tort Claims Act, Title 15, Chapter 78, can control the claim, including whether a wrongful death theory is available against that entity and what limits apply. Two timing rules from that Act must be flagged in any such case.
Section 15-78-110 provides that an action under the chapter is forever barred unless it is commenced within two years after the date the loss was or should have been discovered, with the extension the section and related sections provide when a claimant first filed a claim under the chapter, in which case the action period becomes three years from that date. Section 15-78-80 governs the filing of a claim under the chapter. It addresses a verified claim setting out the circumstances that brought about the loss, the extent of the loss, the time and place the loss occurred, the names of all persons involved if known, and the amount of the loss sustained, filed with the entity the Act designates, within the time that section allows, commonly one year from the loss for the verified claim step that supports the longer filing period.
In plain terms, a government case can require action within the first year to preserve a third year to sue, and will be barred at two years if that step is not taken. Road defect cases, public hospital cases, school cases, and crashes involving government vehicles are the settings where families most often meet this Act. Damage limits in the Tort Claims Act can also cap recovery against a governmental entity, a further reason to identify every non government defendant and every insurance policy in the case. If there is any chance a government body is involved, treat the first year, not the third year, as your working deadline and get advice at once.
Frequently Asked Questions About Wrongful Death Claims in South Carolina
Can a spouse file a wrongful death lawsuit without opening an estate?
No. Section 15-51-20 requires the action to be brought by or in the name of the executor or administrator of the deceased person. A spouse who is appointed personal representative files in that role, for the benefit of the statutory beneficiaries. An estate must be opened and the appointment made before suit is filed and before a settlement can be approved under Section 15-51-42.
If there is a spouse and also parents, do the parents share in the recovery?
Under the order in Section 15-51-20, no. The action is for the benefit of the spouse and children first. Parents benefit only if there is no spouse and no child. Heirs benefit only if there is no spouse, no child, and no parent. Section 15-51-40 then divides a recovery among the entitled parties in intestate shares, subject to the parent support limitation that section allows a probate court to apply.
What is the difference between the wrongful death claim and the survival claim in one settlement check?
The wrongful death claim pays the statutory beneficiaries for their losses from the death, including lost support, loss of companionship, and grief and mental anguish. The survival claim pays the estate for the deceased person own losses before death, including conscious pain and suffering and medical expenses, when proved. Funeral expenses may be included under either claim, but only once, under Section 15-5-100. A combined settlement must allocate the total between the claims, and a court must approve the settlement under Sections 15-51-41 and 15-51-42.
How long do we have if a city or state vehicle caused the death?
Expect a shorter clock. Under the Tort Claims Act, Section 15-78-110 bars an action not commenced within two years after the loss was or should have been discovered, with a three year period available when a verified claim was first filed under the chapter as Section 15-78-80 provides. Protect the one year verified claim step. Do not plan around three years in a government case without advice.
Can we settle quickly without going to court at all?
You can negotiate without filing suit, but you cannot complete a wrongful death or survival settlement without court approval. Section 15-51-41 requires approval by a probate court, a circuit court, or the United States District Court, under the process in Section 15-51-42. Build that hearing into your timing expectations.
What if our family member was partly at fault for the accident?
Partial fault reduces recovery under South Carolina modified comparative negligence from Nelson v. Concrete Supply Co., and fault greater than the defendant fault bars recovery. Insurers will build the strongest fault case they can. Preserve vehicles, records, and witness names at once so your side of the fault proof is not lost.
Speak With a South Carolina Wrongful Death Lawyer When You Are Ready
Traywick Law Offices, LLC represents South Carolina families in wrongful death and survival claims with the care these cases require. At a free consultation we will identify who must be appointed personal representative, map the beneficiaries under Section 15-51-20, confirm the deadline under Section 15-3-530(6) or the Tort Claims Act, and outline what proof will be needed on fault and damages. There is no pressure to decide more than the next step at that meeting.
Call Traywick Law Offices at (843) 343-5092, or request a review through our free consultation intake. Our online address is 38 Romney St, Suite 104, Charleston, SC 29403. If the death involved a government entity or vehicle, call sooner rather than later. The first year holds a claim step that cannot be recovered once it passes.